Casa 43 Mexican Food Menu

Casa 43 Mexican Food Menu
All recipes are made from scratch using only the freshest ingredients available. Homemade tortillas and fresh squeezed juices.

KITCHEN CLOSES at 10:30 PM nightly.

All prices in Cayman Island Dollars. CI$


Warm Tortilla Chips with Trio of Salsas5.95

Tomatillo serrano, fire roasted tomato chile de arbol, and pico de gallo

Guacamole Trio Tasting13.95

Guacamole tasting trio with warm in house made tortilla chips!

Homemade Guacamole8.95

Fresh avocado, tomato, lime, cilantro, green onion, serrano chili

Grilled Pear and Bacon Guacamole9.25

Local mango and scotch bonnet guacamole - YUM!

Roasted Corn + Cotija Cheese Guacamole9.25

Roasted corn and cotija cheese guacamole - fan favorite!

Mexico City Street Corn!!5.95

Mexico City street corn fired on the grill after being brushed with melted butter then topped with Cotija cheese and served on a little bit of pesto aioli.

Signature Chicharrón Chips5.95

Crispy fried pork rind, dusted with house made spices and grilled green onion, served with cilantro and chili vinaigrette - so addictive you may come back just for these!!!

Baby Back Ribs9.95

Chef Lloyd's Ancho chile dry rub, finished with a tangy guava glaze and almost fall off the bone deelishousness!

Queso Fundido with Chorizo11.95

Melted menonita, Oaxaca, and cotija cheeses, Mexican dark beer, and chorizo served with homemade tortilla chips - order a few of our hand made corn tortillas - $1.50 ea - for the true Mexcican way!

Tostones de carnitas9.95

Braised pork with a hint of pineapple, shredded cabbage, pico de gallo with Mexican crema served on crispy fried plantain

Duck Confit Chilaquiles11.95

A traditional Mexican dish in our unique style served with a free range egg, salsa verde, crema, queso cotija, and pico de gallo - you GOTTA break the egg - it makes the dish!

Tuna Volcano!!!13.50

Prepared in soy lime on a bed of arugula and avocado with borracho
onions and a ginger avocado mousse.

Caribbean Shrimp12.50

Lightly poached fresh shrimp marinated in lime juice with fresh mango, advocado, cilantro, and a touch of scotch bonnet pepper.

Peruvian style red snapper12.50

Fresh snapper in a coconut milk and lime marinade with fresh tomato, a touch of habanero pepper, cilantro and scallions.

Trio Tasting of Ceviches16.95

Get a FLAVA of all three - great to share! Tuna Chino-Latino, Caribbean shrimp and Peruvian snapper.

Tortilla Soup6.43

Tomato base with roasted corn, avocado, shredded chicken, queso fresco, crispy tortilla chips - go traditional and add handmade corn tortillas for $1.50 each.

Vegetarian Black Bean Soup5.43

No meat stock in here! Served with Mexican crema and fried corn tortilla strips.

Mexican green salad9.95

Baby greens and arugula, with spiced pepitas, jicama. avocados, tomato, roasted peppers and radish with a honey chipotle lime dressing

Casa 43 Caesar Salad9.95

Charred hearts of romaine and spring onion, creamy cilantro dressing, cotija cheese, crispy masa crouton and cripsy roasted anchovy filets (ask for them on the side if this is not your thang!)

Max's CHUNKY avocado salad with grilled shrimp!12.95

Chunky cubes of avocado, tomato, cucumber and red onion topped with grilled shrimp and served with a chili lime vinegarette - YUMMEE!!!
Substitute grilled chicken breast $5.00 / grilled Mahi $6.00 / 3 Jumbo shrimp $12.00

Taco de lengua5.95 each

Slow braised beef tongue with a farm style smoked tomatillo sauce, red onions, cilantro

Carne Asada5.95 each

Marinated Certified Angus Beef steak, chimichurri, radish, shaved onion, corn tortilla.

Beef Barbacoa5.95 each

House smoked beef brisket, ancho chile rub, caramelized onions, cotija cheese, guacamole.

Chicharron5.95 each

Fried pork belly, onion, cilantro, salsa verde, fresh cabbage, corn tortilla.

Barbacoa De Chivo5.95 each

Slow braised local goat, homemade pickles, radish, crema, and fresh lime, corn tortilla.

Grilled Pollo5.95 each

Grilled chicken, borracho style red onions and jalapenos, grilled pineapple, fresh cabbage and pico de gallo

Puerto Bello Taco5.00 each

Grilled and sliced Portobello mushroom marinated in roasted garlic and balsamic vinegar, with guacamole, cabbage, pico de gallo and cotija cheese

Pescado5.95 each

Grilled mahi, pico de gallo, guacamole, manchego cheese, fresh cabbage, crema, flour tortilla. Sub CORN tortilla - $0.50

Fried Rock Shrimp6.50 each

Tecate beer battered rock shrimp, sriracha aioli, bacon guacamole, pico de gallo, flour tortilla. Sub CORN tortilla - $0.50

The Fried Avocado Taco5.00 each

Crispy queso cotija, poblano pesto, roasted tomato, corn tortilla, squeeze of lime!

The GRINGO Taco5.95 each

Mexican spiced ground beef, lettuce, cheddar cheese, pico de gallo, sour cream in our HOMEMADE CRIPSY CRUNCHY FLOUR TORTILLA

The CHINO LATINO Taco6.50 each

Fresh tuna tossed in Allan’s homemade Asian marinade, wakame salad, avocado, toasted sesame seeds in our HOMEMADE CRIPSY FLOUR TORTILLA

Enchiladas verdes de carnitas12.95

Slow braised pork with a hint of pineapple served with our homemade green tomatillo sauce , Mexican crema, queso fresco and pico de gallo

Dos Enchiladas12.95

Marinated chicken served in homemade corn tortillas baked in our signature ranchero OR mole sauce topped with queso fresco, crema Mexicana, and pico de gallo.

Vegetarian Tamales9.95

Steamed masa in a fresh corn husk, filled with chick peas, carrots, and green beans and drizzled with achiote oil - great vegetarian option OR add shredded chicken or braised beef brisket for $5.00

Burritos Wet or DrySee Description

Mexican Rice, Refried Beans, Queso Fresco, Guacamole, Pico de Gallo, Sour Cream

• Pork, Chicken, Ground Beef or Goat - 13.95

• Steak or Mahi - 16.95 • Shrimp - 17.95

• “Naked” burrito bowl in cast iron skillet

El Mexicano Burger13.95

In house made beef burger, bacon guacamole, pepper jack cheese, roasted tomato mayonnaise, topped with a bacon wrapped and pepper jack cheese stuffed jalapeno - WOWZA!!! - served with smoked chili fries and chipotle aioli - I'm :LUVIN it!!!!

Snapper Veracruz23.95

Pan roasted fresh local snapper served with a Veracruz style sauce of tomatoes, olives, onions, and capers, served with mashed local plantains and callaloo.

Casa 43 Steak Frites!!!24.95

10 OZ flank steak with our signature FLAVAS served with cotija garlic fries, and Chef Allan’s hand crafted smoked red and mint green chimichurri dipping sauces.

Lobster Enchiladas25.95

3 lobster enchiladas flour tortillas guajillo cilantro tomato sauce - earthy - hint of spice.

Grilled Chicken Quesadilla12.50

Grilled chicken, pepper jack cheese, crispy bacon, caramelized onions served with pico de gallo and Mexican crema!

Casa 43 Steak Frites!!!24.95

10 OZ flank steak with our signature FLAVAS served with cotija garlic fries, and Chef Allan’s hand crafted smoked red and mint green chimichurri dipping sauces.

Lobster Quesadilla16.95

Fire roasted lobster, creamy pepper jack cheese, pico de gallo, cilantro, siracha aioli with crema and salsa verde!

Sizzling Fajitas make them your own!You choose

Sizzling Fajitas served SMOKIN HOT!!! - Green and red peppers, onions, pepper jack cheese, pico de gallo, guacamole, sour cream

- Chili mojo marinated chicken or flank steak or combination - $19.95
- Shrimp or Mahi Mahi or any combination - $24.95

Fajitas set ups and tortilla optionsSee below

- Sub corn tortillas $5
- Extra setup flour tortillas and all sides add $10.95
- Extra setup corn tortillas and all sides add $15.95
- Extra pico de gallo, pepper jack cheese, sour cream $1.50 each
- Extra guacamole $3.95

Mexico City rice3.50

Mexico City rice - a great add on to any appetizer or meal.

Fried Sweet Plantains3.00

A Caribbean favorite - try a little lime on this lightly fried and delish sweet plantains.

Vegetarian Black Beans3.50

Vegetarian black beans - get these and the rice - VOILA!

Refried Pinto Beans3.50

Mashed and refried pinto beans as a great addition to any dish!

Sweet Potato fries3.95

Thin cut sweet potato fries served with a chipotle aioli - the healthier option?

Smoked Chile-Lime Fries3.95

You GOTTA try these - salted with our in house smoked chile-lime salt.

Handmade CORN tortilla1.50

Fresh handmade corn tortilla

FLOUR Tortillas1.00

FLOUR tortilla

Cotija Cheese and Garlic Fries4.25

Finally chopped garlic, hot fries and cotija cheese!!!

Fried Ice Cream8.43

A large scoop of vanilla ice cream rolled in a crispy tortilla coating then deep fried and served with a yummy salted cajeta sauce! This sauce by itself will drive you wild but FRIED ICE CREAM - Que RICO!!!!!

Mexican Chocolate & Ancho Chile Lava Muffin8.43

Mexican Chocolate and Ancho Chile Chocolate Lava Muffin with fresh strawberries and ... well ... you will just have to try this one!

Kahlua Crème Brûlée (Gluten Free)8.43

A gluten free dessert this crème brûlée is FLAVA'd with a Mexican coffee liqueur - yes Kahlua is Mexican!


Say no more! Made fresh to order they are so light and tasty that you will be wondering how we do this! Lightly dusted with cinnamon sugar and served on a blend of salted cajeta and ancho-chocolate sauce.

Churro BASKET!8.43

Basket made out of our famous CHURROS filled with vanilla ice cream, topped with cajeta and chocolate spaces and garnished with fresh strawberries!!!

Tres Leche Cake - WOW!!!8.43

Chef Liberia's famous Puebla tres leches sponge cake - this is a MUST have!!!

Aztec Albondigas6.50

4 bite size beef Mexican meatballs with a touch of spice
Oaxaca cheese and ranchero sauce- $6.50

El Luchador 4.50 each

Casa 43’s famous Mexi burger in a bite size bun

Acapulco Fish and Chips6.00

2 tempura fried ancho chili rubbed snapper filet fingers with fries.

Queretaro Ranchero Spring Roll3.00 each

Ground beef, cheese, green cabbage and crema wrapped in a crispy flour tortilla!

Mexican Bullets2.50 each

2 bacon wrapped cheese stuffed jalapeños.

Bryan’s Famous Chicken Empanadas4.50

The homemade touch with pulled chicken and cheese.

Mexica City Street Corn3.00 each

1/2 an ear of our FAMOUS Mexico City street corn - YUMMEEEEEEE!!!!!!

Beer Selection4.00

Heineken, Caybrew, White Tip, Dos XX

Premium Beers4.00

Corona, Corona Light, Tecate, Bohemia

House Wine6.00

White / Red / Zinfandel

Casa 43 Signature Margarita 7.95

Our world class margarita with Herradura tequila, fresh squeezed lime juice and homemade simple syrup!

Mango Margarita 8.95

Our world class MANGO margarita with Herradura tequila, fresh squeezed lime juice and homemade simple syrup!